The
purpose of this unit is to provide the Parenting Support Specialists (PSS)
with an overview of violence and its impact on the functioning of society,
the family, and the development of its children. Included will be a discussion
of the societal and individual factors that contribute to violence and abuse.
The legal definition of abuse and neglect in the District of Columbia, the
requirements for reporting, penalties for not reporting, and designated
personnel for receiving reports of abuse and neglect in the District will
be discussed. Procedures for the reporting of suspected abuse and neglect
by the PSS will be outlined.
| Objectives
|
By
the end of this unit, the participants will be able to:
- Define
interpersonal violence.
- List five
cultural factors that contribute to high violence levels.
- List three
cultural factors that contribute to low violence levels.
- Describe
some of the effects of attempting to parent within a chronic,
highly violent environment.
- Describe
the impact of living in a chronically violent environment on
children's development.
- List five
characteristics of the high violence/abusive parent.
- List five
antecedents of violent behavior in children.
- Define
physical, verbal and sexual abuse, and neglect.
- Describe
the typical patterns found in an abusive family.
- Describe
five typical effects of physical abuse on children's behavior
and development.
- List five
symptoms of sexual abuse in children.
- Describe
five factors that decrease the probability of the occurrence
of abuse to children.
- List five
strategies to prevent violence and abuse within the family.
|
|
Time
|
6
1/4 Hours |
|
Outline
|
A. Definition/Overview
of Violence: Facts and Figures.
B. Cultural Attitudes/Characteristics
Related to Violence.
C. Familial Characteristics
Related to Violence.
D. Abuse/Neglect
Issues.
E. Violence Prevention
Strategies.
F. Effective Violence
Intervention Programs.
G. Summary. |
|
Materials
|
- Transparencies/Handouts:
- Statistics
on Violence (Handout #1)
- Cultural
Factors that Influence High and Low Levels of Violence (Handout
#2)
- Effects
of Chronic Violence on Parents and Children (Handout #3)
- Familial
Characteristics Related to Violence (Handout #4)
- Characteristics
of Abusive/Neglectful Behavior in Parents (Handout #5)
- Effect
of Abuse/Neglect on Childrens Behavior & Development
(Handout #6)
- Pride
in Parenting, Abuse and Neglect Guidelines (Handout #7)
- D.C. Government
Pamphlet on Child Abuse Reporting Responsibilities (copies for
all participants)
- American
Psychological Association. (1993) Violence and youth: Psychology's
response. Vol. I: Summary report of the American Psychological
Association Commission on violence and youth. Washington
DC: American Psychological Association.
- Conway,
L.P. & Hansen, D.J. Social Behavior of Physically Abused
and Neglected Children. Clinical Psychology Review. Vol.19,
pps. 627-652.
- Osofsky,
J. D. & Fenichel, E. (Eds.) The Zero to Three Study Group
on Violence. Caring for Infants and Toddlers in Violent Environments:
Hurt Healing and Hope. Arlington VA: NCCIP.
- Post Unit
Test
- Post-Unit
Evaluation
- Blackboard
and chalk, or easel with paper and markers
- TV, VCR,
tripod, video camera, video tapes
|
| Advance
Preparation
|
- If needed,
arrange for an expert in abuse and neglect and local reporting
procedures to speak to group
- Review
above listed articles
- Review
handouts and make needed transparencies and sufficient number
of copies of handouts
- Set up
and test video equipment; setup camera to record session
|
A. DEFINITION/OVERVIEW
OF VIOLENCE: FACTS AND FIGURES
(1 hour)
| Rationale:
|
The
purpose of this training session is to give the PSS a picture of
the scope of violence and its effect on the family environment. |
|
Procedure:
|
- Review definition
of violence as follows. Discuss examples of the
general situations mentioned. Definition: "Violence refers
to immediate or chronic situations that result in injury to
the psychological, social or physical well-being of individuals
or groups. Interpersonal violence is behavior by persons against
persons that threatens, attempts or completes intentional inflection
of physical or psychological harm." APA Commission on Violence
and Youth.
- Participant discussion.
Begin by asking the trainees some of the following questions.
Why has there been such a dramatic increase in the amount of
violence among the young in our society? How does violence within
the community affect the family? How does the level of violence
within the community affect the parents' ability to take care
of their children? How does violence within the community affect
the children? How can parents help their children to be safe
in a high violence area? How much violence should a society
tolerate within the family without sanctions (i.e. between partners,
between parent and child)?
- Summarize the Discussion.
Use the transparency of Handout #1 and have participants
react to the statistics. Distribute Handout #1.
|
B. CULTURAL
ATTITUDES/CHARACTERISTICS RELATED TO VIOLENCE (1
hour)
| Rationale:
|
In
order to understand violence, PSSs must be aware of the factors
promoting high violence and their impact. |
|
Procedure:
|
1.
Make transparency of Handout #2 on cultural characteristics
related to high and low violence societies. Allow the PSS to react
to and discuss each point in relation to our society. Distribute
Handout #2.
2. Effects of
Living in Chronic High Violence Society/Community On: Discuss
what participants believe are the effects of living in a high violence
society/community on parents & children. Be sure to include
the following information.
a. Parents
-
Living in a chronically violent environment may affect parents
ability to nurture, protect and parent their children effectively.
-
Certain parts of the District of Columbia can be considered
a chronic, high violence community. Some of the parents that
you will see may exhibit these characteristics.
Discussion
Question: In what ways can living in a highly violent society
change parenting activities? The trainer can list the changes the
home visitors pose on the board. These additional effects can be
added if the home visitors do not include them.
-
Parents may feel hopeless, overwhelmed and powerless to
provide a safe environment for and protect their children from
ongoing everyday violence.
-
If the parent has been traumatized by violence, he or she
may be unavailable to nurture and provide security for the child.
-
The parents may become hyper-vigilant and overprotect the
child, not allowing him or her to grow and develop normally.
-
If the parent is stressed and depressed concerning violence,
there may be a tendency to be irritable and hostile, particularly
in intimate relationships.
b. Children
-
The exposure to chronic violence affects young children's
view of themselves, the world and their relationships with others
around them.
-
Sometimes children in chronically violent environments may
experience symptoms of post traumatic stress disorder such as
sleeping difficulties, nightmares, eating problems, attention
problems in school, re-enactment of traumatic events, fearfulness
and anxious reactions.
-
Older children may resort to carrying guns or other weapons
out of fear of violence from their peers.
-
Pre-adolescents and adolescents may join gangs for a sense
of security.
|
C. FAMILIAL
CHARACTERISTICS RELATED TO VIOLENCE
(1 hour)
| Rationale:
|
In
order to assist parents in positively impacting their parenting,
PSSs need to know what may cause violent behavior. |
|
Procedure:
|
1.
Review information on Handout # 4 and distribute handout.
Discuss each point. Add any comments by participants to the list.
2. First
ask participants to identify what causes violent behavior in parents
and in children. Make lists.
Causes of Violence
in Parents
- Inadequate
or harsh parenting delivered to them as children.
- Lack
of exposure to role models other than the use of harsh discipline.
- Inadequate
problem solving skills, feelings of powerlessness and inadequacy,
low self-esteem.
Causes of Violence
in Children.
- There
may be biological contributions to aggressive or violent behavior
in children, i.e. basic temperament and activity level. Birth
trauma and other neurological trauma, both prenatally and post-natally
may cause subtle brain damage.
- Early
family influences may also contribute to violent behavior in
children. These influences include: weak or absent nurturing
by a primary caretaker; parental rejection of the child; anti-social
personality of parent; frequent and harsh physical punishment;
lack of parental supervision; the subtle condoning of aggression
by the parents; high levels of watching television violence.
There is a correlation between the amount of watched violence
and acted out violence.
|
D. ABUSE/NEGLECT
ISSUES (2 hours)
| Rationale:
|
In
high violence situations, there is a high risk of abuse and neglect.
Since the PSS may be in these types of environments, it is important
for them to have a good understanding of abuse and neglect and to
be able to recognize it. |
|
Procedure:
|
1.
Depending on the expertise of your trainees, you might arrange for
an expert in abuse and neglect to speak to the group on the information
that follows.
2. Review
and discuss the information and specific examples of the terms defined
below.
Definitions:
a. Physical
abuse is intentional injury that is inflicted on the child
through methods such as beating, burning, scalding, kicking,
throwing, strangling, etc.
b. Verbal
abuse is often called the hidden abuse because it leaves
no visible physical scars, only hidden psychological scars.
Verbal abuse consists of name calling, humiliation, demeaning
the child and his activities, excessive yelling.
c. Sexual
abuse is any indication of parents, guardians or caretakers
engaging in sexual molestation involving a child or any person
engaging in sexual molestation with a child due to the neglect
of the parents.
d. Neglect
is the purposeful withholding of things necessary to the well-being
of the child. These things can consist of adequate food, clothing,
medication and health care, supervision and nurturing.
3. Review
and discuss the following statistics.
a. Severe
abuse occurs in only 4% of reported cases.
b Over
1 million cases of child abuse are reported annually in the
United States.
c Neglect
is more common than abuse.
d. Childhood
accidents and some fatal injuries can be traced to parental
neglect, yet this may not be reflected in the reporting of the
injuries or deaths.
e. There
is a negative correlation of abuse with economics, though abuse
is seen in all class levels and ethnic groups, there is a greater
percentage of abuse seen in the lower socio-economic strata.
4. Discuss
characteristics of abusive/neglectual behavior. Distribute Handout
#5. Have participants give examples that they have observed
or experienced. Include all information in Handout #5.
5. Discuss
what happens to children who are abused. Distribute Handout #6.
Be sure to include information found in Handout #6.
6. Ask
participants what factors may help to prevent abuse and neglect.
Be sure to review the following information.
-
Wanted pregnancy.
-
Initial pregnancy occurs after the teen years.
-
Increased education.
-
Adequate income.
-
Social supports.
-
One study showed that just having a pediatrician call once
a week reduced physical abuse that required emergency room treatment
in experiment to 0%, 10% in control group.
-
Strong kinship bonds.
-
Strong spiritual/religious orientation.
-
Strong work orientation.
-
High achievement orientation.
-
Flexibility of family roles.
7. Arrange
for an expert in local reporting procedures to join the group discussion.
- Legal Responsibilities
for Reporting Suspected Abuse and Neglect.
- Professions
required by law to report suspected abuse and neglect: Doctors,
nurses, child care workers, teachers, social workers.
- Procedures
for reporting.
- Penalties
for not reporting.
- Abuse
and neglect procedures in the District of Columbia. Distribute
this information.
- Procedures
for home visitors to use when abuse or neglect is suspected
during home visits. Distribute and carefully review Handout
#7.
|
E. VIOLENCE
PREVENTION/INTERVENTION STRATEGIES
(1 hour)
| Rationale:
|
When
discussing the issues of violence in our society, it is important
to address prevention and intervention. |
|
Procedure:
|
1. Brainstorm
with group about strategies to prevent violence. Be sure to cover
the following information.
- Criminalizing
abusive behavior, whether physical or sexual seems to be effective.
- Prevention
is most effective when child sexual abusers are treated as criminals.
Family violence tends to be repeated less frequently when the
perpetrator is arrested.
- Teach
children to say "no" to unwanted touching of their
bodies by anybody, including family members.
- Encourage
children not to be afraid to tell parent or other trustworthy
adult about unwanted advances. The child should not be condemned
for coming forward with information.
- Many
physically abused children show amazing resilience if they have
the social support of another family member or other adult,
such as a friend or teacher.
- Two-thirds
of abused children take good care of their children if they
have good social support. Only 1/3 perpetuate the cycle.
- The
adults that seems to fare best are the ones that are openly
angry about the abuse and can discuss and describe their experience
of abuse. Typically they were abused by only one parent, and
not both.
2. Discuss
programs that can be used to intervene to decrease violence.
- Eighty
percent of parents can be helped by working with them to develop
more effective parenting strategies.
- Parent
Abuse Hotline.
- Parents
Anonymous.
- One
of the most important interventions may be adequate medical
care for parents, parental health problems often accompany abuse.
- Some
of the most effective programs are "Home Visitor" programs for
at-risk families which include prenatal and post-natal counseling
and continued contact with family and child in the first few
years of life. In a 20-year follow-up of one such program, positive
effects could be seen for both the at-risk child and for the
mother.
|
G. Summary
and Review (15 minutes)
|
Procedure:
|
- Rephrase the objectives
on the first page of this unit as questions. Ask a volunteer
to answer each question.
- Ask participants
whether the learning objectives they stated at the beginning
of the unit were met. What information do they feel they still
need behavior and discipline.
- Distribute the
post-unit evaluation forms.
- Distribute the
post-unit test.
|
Unit 20 Pst Unit Test
POST-UNIT
TEST
Name ____________
- List
four characteristics of high violence societies.
- List
three characteristics of low violence societies.
- List
three characteristics of high violence families.
- List
three possible effects on the parenting behavior of persons living
in high violence areas.
- List
3 possible effects living in high violence societies on the personality
development of children.
UNIT 20 Handout for use at end of each Unit
Post-Unit
Evaluation
Unit
Covered:_____
Date: _____
- Do
you feel we covered all the information in this unit that we said
we were going to?
- What
did you like best about the unit?
- What
did you like least about the unit?
- Was
the information in this unit presented clearly? If not, please explain.
- In
which skill areas do you feel you need more practice or help?
- How can we make this
unit better?
- Any additional comments?
< face="Times New Roman, Times, serif">
Unit 20 Handout #1
STATISTICS
ON VIOLENCE
- Violence
among youths 11 to 17 has increased 25% in the last decade (Uniform
Crime Statistics, 1992).
- Physical
abuse is the leading cause of death in children less than one year
of age (Waller, Baker & Szocka, 1989).
- Thirty-three
percent of all sexual abuse cases involve children under six years
of age (Schmitt & Krugman, 1992).
- Homicide
is the 2nd leading cause of death among all 15-24 year olds
in the United States of America (National Center for Health Statistics,
1991).
- In
1991, the homicide rate for African-American males 15-24 years of
age was 10 times greater than the rate for 15-24 year old white males
(National Center for Health Statistics, 1991).
- In
1991, 1,383 young children (50% were less than 1 year of age) died
from abuse.
- One
out of ten children under age six attending a Boston Pediatric clinic
had witnessed a shooting or stabbing, either in their homes or on
the street.
- In
a survey of sixth, seventh, eighth and tenth grade students, 30% reported
witnessing at least one crime daily.
- In
1990, 222 children in the United States were killed by handguns.
During 1990, only 68 persons of all ages were killed by handguns
in Canada.
- At
least 3.3 million children witness parental abuse each year. This
includes shootings and stabbings as well as beatings (Jaffe, Wilson
& Wolffe, 1988).
- The
rate of penetrating injury caused by violence in the emergency room
of the Children's National Medical Center increased 1,740% between
the years of 1986 and 1989.
- Forty
to 50% of all American households own a firearm (National Rifle Association).
- Alcohol
is implicated as a factor in over half of all violent attacks in the
home.
Unit 20 Handout #2
CULTURAL
ATTITUDES/CHARACTERISTICS RELATED TO VIOLENCE
Use transparencies on cultural
characteristics related to high and low violence societies. Allow the
trainees to react to and discuss each point for a short period.
1. Characteristics of
High Violence Societies.
- The cultural
or folk heroes demonstrate high levels of violence in their exploits,
i.e. Bonnie and Clyde, cowboys, "bad dudes," such as James Bond, the
Terminator, etc.
- There is a high
level of violent crime in the society. America has the highest murder
rate in the world.
- The citizens
have a right to bear arms and firearms are easily accessible.
- There is a high
level of violence in the entertainment, media, sports and leisure
activities of the society. For example, sports such as football and
LaCrosse, leisure activities such as hunting, war games. Visual and
print media in American society highlight violence. News footage is
much bloodier than it was 20-30 years ago. Movies and television have
gotten bloodier and more violent in the last few decades to the point
that there were congressional hearings last year on the amount of
violence in prime time television.
- Children are
seen as an economic liability.
- There is a lack
of social supports, and no close by extended family. Mother and father,
or single mother alone, have almost total responsibility for child
rearing.
- Primacy of parent/child
relationship and inability of others to interfere.
- High rate of
physical discipline. Ninety percent of Americans spank their children
and feel that it is called for.
- The play of
the children mirrors the violence in the society. War toys and guns
are frequent playthings of young children. Video games are extremely
violent, prompting congressional hearings this year. Toys R Us and
Kaybee Toys will no longer carry realistic looking toy guns.
- In societies
where there is chronic poverty and deprivation among minorities or
the lowest levels of society, violence levels will be high. One of
the side effects of high levels of violence in these strata is family
instability and breakdown.
- The society's
attitude towards and participation with alcohol and other drugs. Drug
use is expensive and drug addicts will commit crimes and violent acts
to get money to support their habits. Alcohol and cocaine use, and
increasingly heroin use, by parents or caretakers is a root cause
of violence against children.
2. Characteristics
of Low Violence Societies.
- Children are
highly valued and often seen as an economic asset.
- The population
tends to be homogeneous.
- The child care
is shared by many, not just the mother and father.
- There is a low
demand level on the behavior of the children. They are rarely punished
before two or three years of age.
- The society
provides sanctions against violent behaviors among its members.
Unit 20 Handout #3
EFFECTS
OF CHRONIC VIOLENCE ON PARENTS AND CHILDREN
A. Parents
- Living in a
chronically violent environment may affect parents ability to nurture,
protect and parent their children effectively.
- Certain parts
of the District of Columbia can be considered a chronic, high violence
community. Some of the parents that you will see may exhibit these
characteristics.
- Parents may
feel hopeless, overwhelmed and powerless to provide a safe environment
for and protect their children from ongoing everyday violence.
- If the parent
has been traumatized by violence, he or she may be unavailable to
nurture and provide security for the child.
- The parents
may become hyper-vigilant and overprotect the child, not allowing
him or her to grow and develop normally.
- If the parent
is stressed and depressed concerning violence, there may be a tendency
to be irritable and hostile, particularly in intimate relationships.
B. Children
- The exposure
to chronic violence affects young children's view of themselves, the
world and their relationships with others around them.
- Sometimes children
in chronically violent environments may experience symptoms of post
traumatic stress disorder such as sleeping difficulties, nightmares,
eating problems, attention problems in school, re-enactment of traumatic
events, fearfulness and anxious reactions.
- Older children
may resort to carrying guns or other weapons out of fear of violence
from their peers.
- Pre-adolescents
and adolescents may join gangs for a sense of security.
Unit 20 Handout #4
FAMILIAL
CHARACTERISTICS RELATED TO VIOLENCE
1. Characteristics
of high violence/abusing parents.
- Often have health
problems that impair their ability to adequately rear their children.
- Lack of knowledge
concerning developmental capabilities, normal behavior patterns of
young children. They may be seen as willful, "He knows what he is
doing."
- Unrealistic
expectations of children's behavior.
- Lack of problem
solving skills, may typically resort to aggression to solve problems.
- Inability to
read and take cues from baby concerning its needs, fear of "spoiling"
child.
- May have mental
illness.
- High levels
of stress within the home due to economic difficulties, lack of adequate
coping skills, family crisis.
- May have cocaine,
heroin or alcohol addiction.
- Typically it
was the mother who abused the children with no or passive male present.
Now social workers are seeing more males as agents of child abuse,
violence, and sexual abuse. Part of this increase may be due to more
reporting of child abuse.
2. Causes of Violence in
Parents.
- Inadequate or
harsh parenting delivered to them as children.
- Lack of exposure
to role models other than the use of harsh discipline.
- Inadequate problem
solving skills, feelings of powerlessness and inadequacy, low self-esteem.
3. Causes of Violence in
Children.
- There may be
biological contributions to aggressive or violent behavior in children,
i.e. basic temperament and activity level. Birth trauma and other
neurological trauma, both prenatally and post-natally may cause subtle
brain damage.
- Early family
influences may also contribute to violent behavior in children. These
influences include: weak or absent nurturing by a primary caretaker;
parental rejection of the child; anti-social personality of parent;
frequent and harsh physical punishment; lack of parental supervision;
the subtle condoning of aggression by the parents; high levels of
watching television violence. There is a correlation between the amount
of watched violence and acted out violence.
Unit 20 Handout #5
CHARACTERISTICS
OF ABUSIVE/NEGLECTFUL BEHAVIOR IN PARENTS
1. Typical
Profile of Abusing Family.
- Patterns of
physical violence between spouses.
- More disorganized,
chaotic households (those that do not stress the importance of regular
predictable schedules and routines such as meal times, early bedtimes,
etc.)
- The majority
of the abuse of the children occurs at home.
- Frequently it
was the mother that was the abuser, with the father absent or passive.
Today we are seeing more of the fatal and sexual abuse of children
perpetuated by males.
2. Characteristics of Neglectful
Parents.
- Apathetic, ignore
children.
- May have been
inadequately parented or neglected.
- Have poor relationship
with baby's father.
- May have had
difficult and complicated pregnancy.
- Inability to
organize a safe, warm home environment for their children.
3. Adults
Who Were Sexually Abused as Children.
- Tend to be fearful,
anxious, depressed, angry, hostile and aggressive, suffer from low
self-esteem, feel stigmatized, isolated.
- May be sexually
maladjusted.
Unit 20 Handout #6
EFFECT OF
ABUSE/NEGLECT ON CHILDRENS BEHAVIOR AND DEVELOPMENT
1. Characteristics
of Abused Children.
- May trigger
abusive behavior of parents through no fault of his own.
- May have been
an unwanted pregnancy and birth, wrong sex.
- May remind mother
of hated father.
- May have been
low birth weight infant with physical problems or disabilities.
- May have a temperament
that is not congruent with that of the mother or of her expectations.
- 2. Early Signs of
Abuse/Neglect.
- Absence of synchrony
(Infant and parent may seldom make eye contact with each other).
- Failure to thrive,
gain weight or grow normally and achieve developmental milestone in
a timely manner.
3. Impact of Physical Abuse
on Development on Children.
- Delays in speech.
- Preschoolers
may be less independent, more resistant to, yet dependent on their
mothers.
- Tendency to
be less persistent in tasks such as solving puzzles.
- More negativistic,
less enthusiastic.
- Exhibit more
hyperactive behavior and are more likely to be easily distracted.
- Tend to be more
hostile and anxious.
- Exhibit more
aggressive verbal and physical behavior towards their peers and adults.
- As teenagers,
they may exhibit wide variety of physical, cognitive and emotional
disorders.
4. Effects of Neglect on
Children.
- Neglected children
tend to display less self-confidence and self-assertiveness.
- May lack persistence
and the ability to stick to tasks.
- May exhibit
apathy and frequently withdraw from situations.
- May be non-compliant
and easily distracted.
- Tend to be less
aggressive than children who have been physically abused.
- More likely
to be victims of violence.
5. Symptoms of Sexual Abuse
in Children.
- Extreme changes
in behavior.
- Loss of appetite.
- Sleep disturbances,
fear of sleeping alone, nightmares.
- Regression to
earlier forms of behavior, such as bed wetting, thumb sucking.
- Vaginal or rectal
bleeding or discharge.
- Vaginal or throat
infections.
- High irritability.
- Painful, itching
or swollen genitals.
- Early precocity
or interest in sexual matters.
- Intense fear
or dislike of being left with a particular person.
- Increase in
temper tantrums and other acting out behavior.
- Learning disabilities
such as inability to concentrate, falling grades, lack of interest
in school and school activities.
Unit 20 Handout #7
PRIDE
IN PARENTING
ABUSE AND NEGLECT GUIDELINES
For Intervention Families:
When there
is some concern about a family and there are thoughts about a possible
protective service referral:
- PSS should share
concerns with IDS who should alert FRS and establish if there are
shared concerns.**
- The same would
be true if the FRS had the initial concerns.
- Concerns should
also be share with site supervisors.
- IDS might make
a joint visit to the family with the PSS.
- A written summary
of major concerns should be sent to project coordinator with plans
to help mother better the situation. This should also be placed in
the permanent file.
If concerns persist or feeling
is action of an immediate nature is needed:
- Team should
meet, including PSS, IDS, FRS and site supervisor, and reach a consensus*
as to the action to be taken.
- BEFORE ANY ACTION
IS TAKEN, the IDS involved should notify project coordinator. The
project coordinator will contact the principal investigator. The project
coordinator will then direct the staff as to what should be done,
how and by whom. Another paragraph stating lack of change and continued
concerns should go to the project coordinator; this should also be
placed in the permanent file.
For
Control Families:
- Since the FRS
is the only staff involved, if there are concerns about a family they
should be brought directly to the project coordinator.** The project
coordinator will contact the principal investigator and then direct
the FRS as to how to proceed.
- Written documentation
should go in the permanent file as well as to the project coordinator.
* If no
consensus can be reached, the project coordinator should be contacted.
** If there
is a perceived threat of life, contact CPS immediately. Notify the project
coordinator subsequently.